Functions of Privacy:
Insights from Encrypted Messaging App Users

February 13th, 2025

Authors: Sarah Gilbert; Amanda Vilchez; Alexandra Gonzalez

In the first two weeks after taking office, President Trump has signed 45 executive orders, many of which infringe on the rights of Americans to protest, to access healthcare and even to exist. As with prior changes to laws that affect the security of vulnerable groups, privacy experts are renewing calls for at-risk groups to protect their communications through encryption. The Trump administration’s ties to figures like Elon Musk, exacerbate the the need for secure communications. In two weeks, Musk, who owns X, has been authorized to run the newly minted Department of Government Efficenecy (DOGE). The organization has already gained access to the Treasury Department’s payment system, putting Americans’ most sensitive data in the hands of a man who doubted the security of popular encrypted messaging applications, and who may potentially influence a focus on adopting less rigid encryption policies. Prior Trump administration comments have also echoed anti-encryption sentiments when former U.S. Attorney General William Barr said, “It is hard to overstate how perilous this is… By enabling dangerous criminals to cloak their communications behind an impenetrable digital shield, warrant-proof encryption imposes huge societal costs.” While the current Trump administration hasn’t (yet) weighed in on encryption, these actions in conjunction with the onslaught of executive orders raise significant concerns about potential future policy decisions. We need privacy more than ever.  

These are uncertain times for a lot of people. For those who may be looking to encryption to keep them safe, we’re sharing some early findings from our research about how people who use encrypted messaging apps. Our project, Operation Candado, is led by the Citizens and Technology Lab at Cornell University. Our aim is to address the challenge of maintaining user privacy while protecting users from harmful content. To learn more about what people experience on encrypted apps, we’ve distributed  through an open-ended survey to share their stories and voice their needs for encrypted messaging applications. Our goal is to amplify marginalized voices typically overshadowed by government entities and tech giants despite these individuals being the most affected by messaging technology policy changes. 

Privacy As A Right:

Our participants often described privacy as a right. They emphasized the belief that privacy is an inherent human right, akin to other fundamental rights, that should be protected universally, without question or justification. One respondent said: 

…I believe privacy is a human right, and I don’t feel like a lot of messaging apps take it as seriously as they should. I personally don’t “have anything to hide”, but other people might, such as journalists and activists. Pushing for and normalizing private and secure communication technology helps protect those people. 

They expressed that considering privacy as a fundamental human right is critical as it protects other essential liberties, including freedom of speech, protection against discrimination, and freedom from harassment. Thus, this right to privacy provides the basis for developing a democratic society that supports general freedoms for all. 

Privacy As Protection:

Our participants also described how privacy serves as a form of protection, where they used privacy to safeguard themselves from external threats. A respondent noted that:   

…Sensitive information is a matter between myself and the communications partners. None of ‘bad actors’, nation state actors (e.g. intelligence agencies) or corporations (ad tech, social media, …). Thus it needs to be protected, no matter how harmless/vanilla/benign the data is…

Participants described how these applications safeguard user privacy by protecting account credentials and personally identifiable information, restricting data access to intended recipients exclusively, helping them have more control over who sees their personal information and how it’s used. They saw these features as providing greater autonomy in creating, sharing, and distributing their data.

Privacy As An Application Feature:

Participants viewed privacy as one of many features available in digital applications. One respondent described how they use the encrypted messaging app, Signal: 

…I use Signal for most of my sensitive conversations, and use the disappearing messages feature to make sure as little trace as possible is kept when exchanging sensitive information…

When additional security features, like disappearing messages, are layered onto secure messaging applications, they can create an enhanced protection system, as described by our participants. More vulnerable users may require these features. Another participant described their experiences: 

…Safety and security can be a matter of life or death when there is intimate partner violence involved…these services are extremely crucial to safety planning for individuals, families, and communities.

Our participants described how safety features in these applications can help users escape dangerous situations and regain personal control when feeling powerless.

Understanding how people are currently using encrypted chat applications shows how these communication technologies have evolved from simple messaging into critical physical and personal safety tools. We hope our participants’ experiences can help people understand their own privacy needs, and how encryption can help. 

References: 

https://www.cnn.com/interactive/2024/04/politics/trump-campaign-promises-dg

https://freedom.press/issues/three-press-freedom-threats-during-trump-20

https://www.techpolicy.press/what-trumps-return-means-for-encryption


Preliminary Results

October 27th, 2024

Authors: Sarah Gilbert; Amanda Vilchez; Alexandra Gonzalez

In August 2024, Pavel Durov, the founder of Telegram, was arrested by French authorities for purportedly allowing the spread of misinformation, conspiracy theories, neo-Nazi, paedophilic, and terror-related content, bringing global attention to safety issues on apps that offer end-to-end encryption (E2EE). E2EE is a powerful privacy mechanism that prevents anyone other than message senders and receivers from accessing messages—including the apps themselves. Apps that offer E2EE messaging have become important privacy-protecting tools for activists, organizers, journalists, and people who need privacy to protect their rights. Encryption is not offered to Telegram users by default, meaning that the platform could have reviewed content shared on the app; however, this is not the case for similar apps. How can we tackle issues like harassment and hate speech without compromising user privacy?

The Citizens and Technology Lab is leading a new project that tackles this question by shifting the conversation beyond just legal experts, engineers, and law enforcement. We know that users, community organizers, parents, and group moderators—those who interact with these platforms daily—have a lot to contribute. To reach these groups, we’ve developed a survey (that uses end-to-end encryption to protect people’s privacy and is offered in English and Spanish) so that we can reshape the conversation around regulation and content moderation in encrypted spaces by amplifying their voices and creating space for these conversations. 

So far we’ve heard from 106 people and this is what we’ve learned. 

On Privacy:

Privacy is the most significant concern among the people we’ve heard from. People are worried about who can access their data, from platforms, government, advertisers, and even other users. Not all apps are considered equal either—many participants expressed skepticism about the trustworthiness of certain apps. 

People are also really concerned about what information could be violated. We anticipated concerns about powerful people, groups, and governments accessing their messages and misusing them. But we learned that they’re not just worried about the messages they exchange being revealed—they’re also worried about secondary information that can be exposed. For example, they described how it feels like a privacy violation when they’re notified when a contact joins the app. The need for confidentiality extends beyond message content and also includes metadata like contacts, as well as interaction and behavior patterns.

What happens when privacy is violated matters. Participants described fear of police repression, imprisonment, and threats to their security—particularly in regions with restricted freedom of speech. Our participants noted that these threats mean that privacy is crucial for democracy, with some viewing privacy as a human right that platforms need to safeguard. 

On Content Moderation

While everyone agreed that privacy is important, we observed very varied opinions on content moderation. Only a few participants mentioned instances where their own messages were removed or reported and not many participants had reported content either. When they did, it primarily involved racist, homophobic, interpersonal conflict-related content, inappropriate material from strangers, and especially spam. Despite trying to report this content, they found the process to be ineffective or even corrupt. A smaller group of respondents appreciated the moderators’ efforts but called for more rigorous group moderation.

What We Don’t Know

We are still looking for more stories for our study! 

We are especially eager to hear from people who use apps like WhatsApp, Telegram, Signal, and Messenger, but who might not consider themselves particularly tech-savvy or who use them for reasons other than privacy (like connecting with friends and family near and far, parent school chat groups, or to chat with groups of people interested in things you care about). 

We also want to hear from Spanish-speaking participants. These applications are not exclusive to English-speaking nations and we want to learn about what you think. 

If any of this sounds like you (and even if it doesn’t!) and you want to make your voice heard, please consider responding to our survey! English | Spanish


Study Launch

In 2023, we began formulating and designing this study, “New frontiers in online privacy: group moderation in end-to-end encrypted messaging applications,” funded by The National Science Foundation. We seek to incorporate users’ voices into conversations and debates held in the political, business, and academic spheres.